Showing posts with label Depressuring. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Depressuring. Show all posts

Basic Depressuring - Why 15 minutes ?

In previous posting, we have discussed that PSV wouldn’t provide adequate protection for vessel of fire case. Therefore, depressuring can be applied for another safety layer.

Commonly the plant area is divided into the ESD Zone. Each ESD zone may contain one or more equipments. ESDV or SDV valves are provided in each ESD Zone to isolate the system zone. In case of fire, a system will be isolated by those SDV valves. Then the inventory fluid (commonly gas phase only) in the system will be released to flare through BDV valve. Commonly one BDV is provided for one system zone, but in some cases, it is possible to provide more than one BDVs in one system zone.


See the picture.

EDP (Emergency Depressuring) is generally initiated by manual push button. In case of fire, the operator will push the EDP push button in the control room. That will initiate SDV valves closing and BDV valves opening. The hydrocarbon fluid will be released to flare so that the pressure of the system will be depressurized to lower pressure at certain time (recommendation from API STD 521, decrease the pressure to 100 psig or 50 % of the system design pressure within 15 minutes)

For example, If a pool fire exposes the un-wetted carbon steel vessel, it will take about 15 minutes to heat the vessel wall to around 1 200 °F (very close to material’s allowable stress condition). If the vessel is depressurized within the 15 min to 50 % of the initial pressure, then the time to rupture would increase to about 2 - 3 hour "

Hope this picture will give better explanation

For thickness of vessel less than 1 inch, the system is depressurized to 100 psig, and for more than 1 inch thickness can be depressurized to 50% of design pressure. The depressuring time can be longer and less than 15 minutes. The depressuring time of 15 minutes is only an example in API STD 521 which is applicable for carbon steel vessel with has thickness greater than 1 inch.

Consideration of limiting flare capacity, the depressuring time longer than 15 minutes may be applied. It will result in lower depressuring load. Considering of the maximum reduction of the vessel stress, vessel with thickness less than 1 inch, generally requires faster depressuring rate. The faster the depressuring time, the higher the depressuring load. And for the vessel with stainless steel material, the depressuring rate may be longer than 15 minutes for 1 inch thickness or more.

Based on my experience, many companies have their own manual for conducting depressuring study. Generally, the maximum depressuring time of 15 minutes is applied. But each company has difference consideration of thickness vessel and depressurized pressure. Some companies apply that for thickness greater than 24.5 mm, the pressure is depressurized to 50% of design pressure, but other companies apply that for thickness greater than 60 mm the pressure can be depressurized to 50% of design pressure.

I have ever read discussion in Cheresources ( check here and here) about the depressuring time, one of the participants says that his company applies the depressuring time which depends on the vessel thickness. For thickness greater than 25.4 mm, 15 minutes depressuring time is applied. The depressuring time will be decreased 3 minutes for each 5 mm decrease in thickness.

Yesterday, I checked to API STD 521, (Fifth Edition, Jan 2007), figure 1 (section 2.15.1.2.2), the graphic show “ Plate Temperature vs Time After Fire “ for carbon steel 3.2 mm, 12.7 mm and 25.4 mm thickness. It is very logic that the required depressuring time for those vessel are different each other. In my opinion, it is better to state in manual ‘the depressuring time will be decreased, say 2 or 3 or xx minutes, for each 5mm decrease in thickness”.

Oh,,I miss something important. Even though the depressuring time of 15 minutes is used, the depressurization will not stop after 15 minutes and that the pressure will continue to decline.

Ha ha ha,,I guess you already know that :D

Let’s imagine, a PLANT is shutdown for annual maintenance purpose, the fire does not exist, then the system is to be depressurized to atmosphere condition. In this case, the system is depressurized in adiabatic condition, which means no heat input to the system. During depressurization, the pressure decreases, and the temperature decreases as well. The final temperature of adiabatic depressuring could be very low. As Process Engineer, we have responsibility to determine the Minimum Metal Design Temperature (MDMT) for each system zone based on the adiabatic depressuring case

My friend, that’s all I can share today. Hopefully it is useful.

Have a great day, my friend...

 Talk back in comment section below and let me know your opinion !
Share:

Relieving Condition Exceed Design Temperature

Equipment design temperature is usually determined based on the maximum temperature plus a certain margin. The margin could be different for each project, say 20F, 25 F or 30F. Conducting rigorous simulation for fire case, the temperature in each stage simulation is set higher than the previous stage by certain interval. Let say, using 10F in interval temperature will result in temperature about 30F higher than the operating temperature at third stage simulation. That is why; relieving temperature for fire case is very often higher than the design temperature. Whether or not increasing rating pipe is required?.

PSV Doesn't Provide Adequate Protection of Fire Case

See the picture below

A Separator has operating temperature of 120 F with design temperature of 145F. Looking at simulation above, in only two stages of temperature increase, the temperature will reach 150F.

After fire, the temperature will increase commonly above the design temperature. And even in some cases, the vessel could rupture before increasing pressure reaches PSV’s setting pressure. In other word, the vessel will have ruptured before the PSV open. Thus, the PSV doesn’t provide adequate protection for the vessel in case of fire.

For example, the following picture show that the metal plate temperature reaches 1200 F in only 15 minutes after fire.
That is, actually, the PSV doesn’t provide adequate protection for the vessel in case of fire. Therefore, some other options for vessel protection from fire case beside the PSV should be considered, such as: 1. Depressuring 2. External cooling 3. External insulation 4. Provide proper drainage

My friend, for now, we already know the fact that PSV will not give adequate protection for vessel in fire case. But, why do we always provide PSV as protection devise of the vessel? Why do we consider for fire case too? That could be a joke, right? In my opinion, that is all to meet the CODE requirement
My friend, a note shall be made, although the relieving temperature is higher than the design temperature, and the PSV is not efficient to protect the vessel against fire, the PSV remain to be designed based on the relieving temperature, since the PSV is installed as a safe guard

Example Case

I still remember, one of our friends has ever asked me; at that time, he did calculation of fire case for instrument air receiver, the relieving temperature was exceeding the maximum allowable for 150# rating pipe. The question was, whether the 150# pipe rating of inlet PSV would be needed to be increased to 300# or not?

Of course NOT, the pipe rating class of 150# does not need to be increased to 300#, since the determination of pipe rating shall based on maximum condition without consider fire case.

Besides that, it is not common to design PSV for instrument air system with fire case. Personally, I prefer calculate the PSV load of instrument air receiver based on blocked outlet case (if it is possible). Furthermore, In some cases, it might not be applicable to size PSV of instrument air receiver based on fire case. Actually, it shall be based on FERA (Fire and Explosion Risk Assessment) justification whether the instrument air receiver included in fire zone or not.

The block outlet case has more possibility occurred than the fire case. Based on my experience, the load of block outlet is also smaller than un-wetted fire case. Therefore, it is better to design PSV of instrument air based on block outlet case than fire case. Moreover, if you still design PSV based on fire case to consider worst case load, that PSV will not provide adequate protection for the vessel: D.

Do you agree with me, don't you?

Talk back in comment section below and let me know your opinion !
Share: